College Football · Analytics
Coaches say scheduling up gets punished: lose to a good team and the poll drops you, beat a cupcake and it never notices. Every final ranking and every non-conference loss, against teams just as strong.
The answer · FBS, 2022-2025
No. A tough non-conference schedule moves a team's final ranking by less than one spot either way, in the AP poll and in the playoff committee's. What moves a team up is beating good teams: each win over a top-25 team is worth about 1.6 committee spots.
Each row is the change in a team's final ranking from one of the softest non-conference schedules to one of the toughest, against teams just as strong. The shaded band is -1 to +1 spot; a bar is highlighted when its whole 95% interval sits inside it.
Final AP poll: +0.03 spots (95% CI -0.62 to +0.72). Less than one spot either way - neither a penalty nor a reward.
Committee ranking: -0.12 spots (95% CI -0.73 to +0.54). Less than one spot either way - neither a penalty nor a reward.
AP poll, same record: +0.55 spots (95% CI -0.07 to +1.22). Unresolved - the interval reaches past one spot, so the data can't rule a small effect in or out.
MethodOrdinary least squares (OLS) regression with one row per FBS team-season (534): its points in the last regular-season AP Top 25 (0 if unranked) - or, for the committee, 26 minus its rank in the last Playoff Committee Rankings (0 if unranked) - on its final v4-state-space rating, strength-tier dummies (the team's final v4-state-space rank: 1-5, 6-10, 11-15, 16-25, 26-40, with 41+ as the baseline), a power-conference indicator (SEC, Big Ten, Big 12 and ACC, the Pac-12 through 2023, and Notre Dame) and its non-conference schedule strength (the average final v4-state-space rating of its non-conference opponents, an FCS opponent counted at that season's lowest FBS rating). "At the same record" adds its regular-season losses.
MethodEach schedule effect is read across the 10th to 90th percentile of non-conference schedule strength (38.7 to 49.7 rating points), in poll spots - AP points over 60.6 a spot. "Neither a penalty nor a reward" means that whole 95% interval sits inside -1 to +1 spots, a bound set after the first run, which found nothing; "unresolved" means the interval reaches past it.
Week to week, AP voters weigh who a ranked team played. By the end of the season, what's left is credit for the good teams it beat.
After a loss
+100 pts
kept per 10 rating points of the winner
After a win
+48 pts
gained per 10 rating points of the loser
Losing to a better team costs less: for every 10 rating points of the team that beat it, a ranked team keeps 100 more AP points, about 2 spots (95% CI +16 to +185, p = 0.003, q = 0.006).
Beating a better team earns more: for every 10 rating points of the team it beat, a ranked team gains 48 more AP points, about 0.8 spots (95% CI +34 to +64, p < 0.001, q = 0.003).
MethodOLS regression with one row per non-conference game played by a team ranked in that week's AP Top 25: its points in the next poll (0 if it fell out) on its points before, the margin, the venue (+1 home, -1 away, 0 neutral) and the opponent's final v4-state-space rating, per 10 rating points. Losses (63) and wins (329) are fitted separately.
Each top-25 win
+1.6 spots
in the committee's ranking
Blue-blood name
-0.4 spots
once wins are counted
Each win over a team in the top 25 is worth +1.6 committee spots (95% CI +0.99 to +2.08, p < 0.001, q = 0.002) and +97 AP points, about 2 spots (95% CI +60 to +127, p < 0.001, q = 0.002) - with strength, record and schedule held equal.
By season's end the name adds nothing clear once wins over good teams are counted: -0.4 committee spots (95% CI -1.83 to +1.08, p = 0.407, q = 0.407) and -31 AP points, about 0.5 spots (95% CI -122 to +49, p = 0.278, q = 0.334).
Schedule, with wins counted (committee): +0.35 spots (95% CI -0.19 to +0.90). Less than one spot either way - neither a penalty nor a reward.
MethodThe two final-ranking regressions with regular-season losses, wins over teams in v4-state-space's final top 25 (conference games included), a blue-blood indicator (Alabama, Ohio State, Michigan, Notre Dame, USC, Texas, Oklahoma, Georgia, LSU, Penn State, Florida State, Tennessee, Florida, Ole Miss and Oregon) and schedule strength added, each of the last three tested with the others held fixed. These six tests get their own Benjamini-Hochberg adjustment.
Texas lost to Ohio State out of conference and finished #13 in the committee's ranking, outside the #10 cut for the playoff field.
Strength tiers
#13
+0.42 spots
Smooth curve
#13
+0.05 spots
Swap Ohio State for a win over a cupcake and Texas finishes #13 in the committee's ranking with the strength tiers (95% #12-#13) and #13 with a smooth rating curve (95% #13). It finished #13 as played. Neither fit puts Texas inside the #10 cut for the playoff in any of 2,000 refits.
Methodv4-state-space replayed week by week from 2022 through 2025, twice: as played (it reproduces the stored ratings exactly) and with Ohio State's side of that game made an FCS team and the result flipped. Each team's committee score (26 minus its rank) then moves by the change in its predicted score from the committee regression with losses added - fitted once with the strength tiers and once with a cubic in the rating in their place, since crossing a tier line moves a prediction a long way. Texas's new rank is counted among every team, refitted on 2,000 bootstrap resamples. The cut is the lowest rank with every team at or above it in the playoff field.
A contender from the Group of 5 played 1.0 games a season against top-25 teams; one from the SEC played 4.7. You can't get credit for beating good teams you don't play.
| Contenders from | Seasons | Top-25 games | Non-conf. | Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Group of 5 | 7 | 1.0 | 0.7 | 0.3 |
| ACC | 12 | 2.7 | 1.0 | 1.5 |
| Big 12 | 13 | 2.8 | 0.5 | 1.4 |
| Notre Dame | 4 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 1.3 |
| Big Ten | 23 | 3.4 | 0.4 | 1.7 |
| Pac-12 | 9 | 3.4 | 0.3 | 1.7 |
| SEC | 32 | 4.7 | 0.5 | 2.3 |
MethodAmong team-seasons in v4-state-space's final top 25: the average number of regular-season games against other teams in that top 25, how many of those were non-conference, and wins in them. Teams outside the power conferences are grouped as Group of 5. A description, not a test - some groups are a handful of team-seasons.
The three final-ranking questions on the model's top 40 only, and with FBS opponents only. AP points or committee spots per 10 rating points of schedule; highlighted when the interval clears zero.
| Question | Every team | Top 40 | FBS opponents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Final AP poll | +2-34 to +40 | -8-109 to +105 | -3-33 to +28 |
| AP poll, same record | +30-4 to +67 | +43-26 to +116 | +20-10 to +50 |
| Committee ranking | -0.11-0.66 to +0.49 | -0.20-1.71 to +1.52 | -0.14-0.63 to +0.32 |
Enough to recreate every number on this page. Each result's own method line above lists its rows, outcome and controls.